Authenticity vs. Addiction

RSSR CHAPTER 6 - Summary and Reflections

Chapter 6, “How Authenticity Works: Will the Real [Your Name Here] Please Stand Up?” from Resolving Spiritual Skepticism in Recovery by Andrew G. Pierce. AVAILABLE ON AMAZON: https://a.co/d/eqpFjfa

This chapter dives deep into the foundational connection between authenticity and recovery, and it unpacks key psychological insights from Gabor Maté and Brene Brown.

Here’s a concise summary of the core concepts and takeaways from Chapter 6:

How Authenticity Works

1. The False Self vs. The True Self

• Our identity is formed in early childhood based on how we believe our caregivers perceive us.

• To maintain attachment and avoid abandonment, children repress their authentic selves if those parts are rejected by caregivers.

• This leads to the creation of a False Self—a personality constructed to gain love and approval.

2. The Cost of People-Pleasing

• Behaviors like always saying yes, ignoring your own needs, and avoiding conflict are seen as “compassionate,” but they're actually risk factors for:

o Addiction

o Depression

o Chronic illness

o Codependency

o Resentment

• These behaviors are forms of passive dishonesty—inauthentic actions that eat away at self-esteem.

3. Resentment and Dishonesty

• Repression of the True Self in favor of attachment leads to resentment, a major driver of addiction.

• Dishonesty comes in two forms:

o Active: lying, cheating, stealing

o Passive: silencing true emotions, people-pleasing, denying one’s needs

4. The Inner Child

• The “Inner Child” remains stuck at the age when the repression began (often around 3).

• This child accumulates emotional tally marks every time we deny our True Self, fueling internalized shame and self-loathing.

5. Abuse and Attraction

• People-pleasers often attract narcissists or controlling partners who exploit their fear of abandonment.

• This reinforces internalized shame and can lead to cycles of unhealthy relationships.

6. The Bonsai Tree Metaphor

• Borrowed from Alan Berger, this metaphor illustrates how individuals warp their True Selves into idealized versions to gain love, like shaping a bonsai tree.

• While externally “perfect,” the person feels hollow and constrained internally.

7. Authenticity as the Antidote

• The path to healing lies in reclaiming authenticity through:

o Honesty: Actively asserting your real thoughts and feelings.

o Vulnerability: Sharing openly, even about shameful or painful things.

o Supportive spaces like ACA (Adult Children of Alcoholics) and 12-Step meetings where authenticity is practiced without judgment or interruption.

8. Redefining Love and Identity

• Dr. Brene Brown defines love as “human connection as a result of authenticity.”

• Those with shame-based identities cannot accept real love—only by shifting the internal identity (the unquestioned beliefs about oneself) can they receive love and connection.

Practical Applications:

• Notice passive dishonesty: When do you say “yes” but mean “no”? When do you repress emotions to avoid rejection?

• Honor the Inner Child: Begin listening to your needs and feelings as valid and worthy.

• Practice vulnerability: Safe settings like ACA, and other 12-Step meetings are key training grounds.

• Rebuild self-esteem with honesty: Start small by expressing your true preferences or setting one boundary.

• Watch Brene Brown’s and Gabor Maté’s videos: These are referenced for deeper insights into shame, authenticity, and healing.

Self-Reflection Prompts

1. False Self vs. True Self

• What qualities or traits did I learn to hide or suppress in order to be accepted or loved?

• In what ways do I still perform for approval rather than act from authenticity?

• What does my False Self look like today? How does it show up in relationships or recovery?

2. Childhood Roots of Inauthenticity

• Can I identify a specific time or pattern in childhood when I began to suppress my feelings or needs to avoid rejection?

• How did my caregivers respond to anger, sadness, joy, or boundary-setting?

3. Passive Dishonesty

• Where in my life do I say “yes” when I mean “no”?

• When have I recently withheld the truth out of fear of upsetting someone?

• How do I feel physically or emotionally after I betray my own needs to please others?

4. Resentment and Suppression

• Who do I currently resent? What unspoken feelings, needs, or boundaries lie underneath that resentment?

• What is one recent example of me being passively dishonest—and how did it affect my self-esteem?

5. Inner Child Healing

• If I could speak directly to the part of me that first felt rejected or unsafe, what would I say?

• What did that child need to hear but never did?

• What do I feel my inner child is asking for today?

Journal Questions for Integration:

1. “I feel authentic when…” Complete the sentence with real-life examples. What activities, people, or spaces allow you to feel like your real self?

2. “When I abandon myself, it looks like…” Describe the behaviors, excuses, or emotions you notice when you are betraying your True Self.

3. Who in my life supports my authenticity? Who makes it harder to be real? Consider whether your relationships allow space for vulnerability and honesty—or encourage performance and suppression.

4. What does it mean to me to “be honest” in all areas of life? Reflect on the difference between active honesty (telling the truth) and passive honesty (living truthfully). Where do you excel? Where do you struggle?

5. How might I begin to reclaim one part of my True Self this week? Think small and actionable: a boundary, a conversation, a truth you’ve avoided, or simply resting when tired.

Optional Exercise: “Letter from the Inner Child”:

Write a letter from your inner child to your adult self. What would they say? What do they need? What have they been waiting to express?

Deep Reflection Prompts: Becoming Your True Self

1. Authenticity vs. Adaptation

• In what ways have I molded myself to meet others’ expectations or avoid rejection?

• What parts of my personality might not be me, but rather protective adaptations?

• What would it feel like to live fully and unapologetically as my True Self?

2. The Fear of Rejection

• Who or what am I most afraid of losing if I assert my True Self?

• Have I ever experienced rejection for being authentic? What happened—and what did I learn?

• What do I fear would happen if I were fully seen and known?

3. Boundaries and Safety

• Do I equate asserting boundaries with selfishness or guilt?

• Where in my life do I need clearer boundaries to become safer to love?

• How does defining my limits actually help others love me more honestly?

Journaling Questions for Integration

4. The Authentication Process

• What stage do I feel I am in (Stage 1: Prevent Relapse, Stage 2: Regain Authenticity, Stage 3: Enhance Spiritual Capacity)?

• What evidence do I have that my False Self is losing control?

• What support systems (meetings, mentors, friends) am I relying on through this process?

5. Loss and Letting Go

• Who in my life might not adapt to my new authenticity?

• What relationships feel conditional or transactional rather than based on mutual truth?

• If someone leaves me because I am finally being honest, what does that say about the relationship?

6. Healing the Inner Child

• What did my inner child need that was never received?

• How have I continued to neglect or marginalize my inner child in adulthood?

• How can I show up for my inner child today—with kindness, protection, and presence?

Resilience & Emotional Growth

7. Courage and Vulnerability

• In what ways have I shown courage this week by being vulnerable?

• Where do I still hide my truth out of fear of judgment?

• What is one “what if” fear I can face today with gentle courage?

8. Rewriting Rejection

• Can I reframe rejection as redirection?

• Have I ever discovered greater alignment or self-worth after someone left or misunderstood me?

• What belief about myself was reinforced or challenged in those moments?

Becoming Safer to Love & Spiritually Grounded

9. Being a Safe Person

• What does being a “safe person to love” mean to me?

• How has my emotional volatility in addiction affected the safety others felt around me?

• How can I offer stability—emotionally, spiritually, and relationally—now?

10. Spiritual Integration

• How does living as my True Self open the door to spiritual connection?

• What feedback (from people, the Universe, or circumstances) have I received when living authentically?

• Do I believe there is a source of love that accepts me completely—even when others cannot?

Bonus Exercise: Visualization – Meeting Your Ideal Self

Close your eyes and imagine meeting your future self—the version of you who is fully authentic, serene, and spiritually grounded.

• What do they look like?

• How do they speak? How do they carry themselves?

• What do they want to tell you about the road ahead?

Write down the conversation. Let it be a dialogue between who you are now and who you are becoming.

MY BOOK IS AVAILABLE ON AMAZON: https://a.co/d/eqpFjfa